Position Specification error

Position Specification error

A question that came up in our WhatsApp group 

We received a drawing from a customer, and we are unclear what is the meaning of the position specification in Figure 1.

(The drawing is an ISO GPS drawing)

ISO GPS clarification for ASME users, with ISO GPS Position may also be used to specify location of a planar surface, while with ASME, position may only control the location of a derived feature or boundary, and Profile must be used to locate a surface.

Position Specification error
Figure 1: Partial section of customer drawing
Position Specification
Figure 2: General image of the part

Answer:

The short answer: position specification in image 1 is meaningless.

Probably the intent was to specify the location of the three counterbores.

If so, then the specification should have been as in Figure 3, the leader line terminating on the outline of the feature or an extension of the outline (but clearly separated from the dimension line)

Position Specification error
Figure 3: Proposed correction (location of the three surfaces

When the leader line of a geometrical specification is terminated by an arrow on the extension of the dimension line of a feature of size, it refers to a derived feature (a median point, a median line, or a median surface). The dimension in the customer’s drawing (Figure 1) is a location dimension of the counterbore from Datum A (not a size dimension) thus, the specification is meaningless.

Conclusion:

When we encounter an unclear specification in a drawing, it may be a mistake.

In such a case, it is better to check and not to guess.

To join our international WhatsApp group for GD&T topics, click here.

For more information about our GD&T training Seminars

Please contact:

Info@TES-tec.net

+972 74 704 7060

or

Fill out the Form 

To learn more about

upcoming On-Line/Frontal GD&T training Seminars

Please contact

Info@TES-tec.net

60 74-704-70 (972)+

or

Fill out the form

contact us